Thursday 5 December 2013

Timneh Parrot and Grey Parrot represent two species

Posted by Nigel Collar

When species are split into two or more new species, there can be serious implications for the conservation status of the newly elevated taxa. For a start, each of the new species will have a smaller range and a smaller population ‒ therefore increasing the chance that it will be considered ‘Threatened’ according to the IUCN Red List. In the case of grey parrots, it also has serious implications in terms of trade monitoring. Here, Nigel Collar of BirdLife International explains the scoring system he uses for taxonomic assignment and why the two ‘old’ subspecies of African Grey Parrot Psittacus erithacus erithacus and P. e. timneh are now recognised by BirdLife as two distinct species.

Using the scoring system of Tobias et al. (2010), BirdLife staff measured the degree of phenotypic differentiation between West African timneh and nominotypical erithacus using a system in which an exceptional difference (a radically different coloration, pattern or vocalisation) scores 4, a major character (pronounced difference in body part colour or pattern, measurement or vocalisation) 3, a medium character (clear difference reflected, e.g., by a distinct hue rather than different colour) 2, and a minor character (weak difference, e.g. a change in shade) 1; a threshold of 7 is set to allow species status, species status cannot be triggered by minor characters alone, and only three plumage characters, two vocal characters, two biometric characters (assessed for effect size using Cohen’s d where 0.2–2 is minor, 2–5 medium, 5–10 major and >10 exceptional) and one behavioural or ecological character may be counted (Tobias et al. 2010). Moreover, under this scheme a parapatric range (where two taxa replace each other across an extremely narrow line, with no gap between populations) scores 3, a narrow zone of hybridisation 2 and a broad zone of hybridisation 1 (these degrees of hybridisation without full character merging reflect different levels of genetic independence).

Left, Grey Parrot (photo: Keith Allison) and Right, Timneh Parrot (photo: Snowmanradio)

The form timneh can be considered distinct at the species level on account of its

                     darker grey plumage (2);
                     maroon (vs bright red) tail (3);



Left, Grey Parrot (photo:L. Miguel Bugallo Sanchez); Right, Timneh Parrot (Photo: Diana Sophia)


                     smaller size (no score yet; measurements not taken);
                     pinkish-grey (vs blackish) upper half of upper mandible (2);



Left, Grey Parrot (photo: Greg Glendell); Right, Timneh Parrot (Photo: Simon Brusland)


                     parapatric distribution (now blurred owing to escapes of taxa either side of the line, but somewhere in eastern Côte d’Ivoire) (3).


The original description (by Fraser 1844) diagnosed the form by ‘its much darker tints of colouring, and the tail-feathers terminating in a point’, and this latter observation proves largely to be correct in specimen material in the Natural History Museum, Tring, with the shaft of each rectrix slightly protracted so as to give the feather tip the shape of a curly bracket (also known as braces, flower brackets and gullwings)—as in: }


Distribution range of Psittacus timneh and
Psittacus erithacus in West Africa 
(distribution data by BirdLife International)
This newly recognised taxon may already be in trouble. The only places across its range where we know for certain that there are ‘reasonable’ numbers of Timneh are the Gola Forest in Liberia/Sierra Leone and on the Bijagós Islands in Guinea-Bissau. Across much of the rest of its range, we either know that it is rare or totally absent, or we do not know about its status. It may well be pretty rare over much of Sierra Leone and Cote d’Ivoire, although it may be faring slightly better in Liberia. What we must do is to conduct research at key sites across its range to determine its status and conservation needs – this is now a high priority.


References
Fraser, L., 1844. Description of three new species of birds. Proc. Zool. Soc. London 12: 37-38


Tobias, J. A., Seddon, N., Spottiswoode, C. N., Pilgrim, J. P., Fishpool, L. D. C. & Collar, N. J. (2010) Quantitative criteria for species delimitation. Ibis152: 724-746.

10 comments:

  1. The captive birds I know sound differently, too. Check on differences in vocalizations in the wild.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Useful article, but the distribution map needs amending to include the western-most distribution of the Timneh parrot, which includes Guinea-Bissau (as the text indicates, with mention of "Bijagós Islands in Guinea-Bissau").

    ReplyDelete
  3. Martim Melo sent this contribution:

    Janine Clemmons has worked on timneh-erithacus vocalisations, finding differences between both. Not sure if she published her work.

    Genetic data is also supportive of the split. In the widely used cytochrome b, a 3% genetic divergence between the two taxa was found. This value is typical of recent species splits in birds (the boundary often lying around the 2% divergence). It was estimated that the two taxa have been evolving in isolation for about the last two million years. See tables 3 and 4 from:

    Melo M, O’Ryan C (2007) Genetic differentiation between Príncipe Island and mainland populations of the grey parrot (Psittacus erithacus), and implications for conservation. Molecular Ecology 16, 1673-1685.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free.

    state employee cashless treatment scheme

    ReplyDelete
  5. African grey parrot for sale | African grey parrot eggs for sale | African grey parrot for adoption | African grey parrot for rehoming | Buy African grey parrot online


    We have well tamed African Grey Congo parrots available if interested please contact us from the information below :Email : info@tybirdsfarm.com.
    Text or Call: +1-540-268-8521
    Website: www.tybirdsfarm.com

    African grey parrot for sale
    African grey parrot eggs for sale  
    African grey parrot for adoption  
    African grey parrot for rehoming    
    Buy African grey parrot online   
    African grey parrots for sale  

    ReplyDelete
  6. kaufen PCP Droge (Phencyclidine)

    kaufen pcp droge, Allgemeine oder Straßennamen: Engelsstaub, Boot, Schwein, Liebesboot, Wack, Ozon, Friedenspille, Staub, Einbalsamierungsflüssigkeit, Raketentreibstoff. Supergras, Superweed, Whacko-Tabak und Killer-Gelenke beziehen sich auf PCP in Kombination mit Marihuana. kontaktiere uns
    Buy jwh-250 near me discreet delivery

    Where to buy etizolam online cheap. Etizolam is a thienodiazepine derivative, also known to be a benzodiazepine through its action via the benzodiazepine receptor. In the United States, it is available for purchase through the internet for the purpose of research. Contact us to buy etizolam online.

    Graupapagei kaufen von Papageienvogelfarm
    Wir sind erfahrene Züchter von Graupapageien.

    Wir bieten Papageien vielen Familien wie Ihrer an und werden auch in den kommenden Jahren wunderbare Ergänzungen von liebenswerten, gesunden Vögeln anbieten. Kontaktiere uns

    ReplyDelete
  7. kaufen PCP Droge (Phencyclidine)
    kaufen pcp droge
    kaufen pcp droge, Allgemeine oder Straßennamen: Engelsstaub, Boot, Schwein, Liebesboot, Wack, Ozon, Friedenspille, Staub, Einbalsamierungsflüssigkeit, Raketentreibstoff. Supergras, Superweed, Whacko-Tabak und Killer-Gelenke beziehen sich auf PCP in Kombination mit Marihuana. kontaktiere uns
    Buy jwh-250 near me discreet delivery

    Where to buy etizolam online cheap. Etizolam is a thienodiazepine derivative, also known to be a benzodiazepine through its action via the benzodiazepine receptor. In the United States, it is available for purchase through the internet for the purpose of research. Contact us to buy etizolam online.

    Graupapagei kaufen von Papageienvogelfarm
    Wir sind erfahrene Züchter von Graupapageien.
    graupapagei kaufen online
    Wir bieten Papageien vielen Familien wie Ihrer an und werden auch in den kommenden Jahren wunderbare Ergänzungen von liebenswerten, gesunden Vögeln anbieten. Kontaktiere uns

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi there,
    Thank you so much for the post you do and also I like your post, Are you looking to Buy Macaws For Sale in the whole USA? We are military macaw baby ,red african grey for sale south Africa, red factor african grey, green naped amazon, double yellow amazon for sale, baby green wing macaw, yellow naped amazon for sale, red factor grey parrot, red factor african grey parrot, hythian macaw, timneh african grey babies for sale, scarlet macaw eggs, yellow headed amazon for sale, african grey baby birds for sale, summer fashion dresses 2018, baby grey parrot for sale, yellow naped amazon talking, baby african gray, african gray red factor, military macaw for sale, indian ringneck parakeet for sale, baby timneh african grey, indian parakeet for sale, blue indian ringneck for sale, yellow naped amazon for adoption, african grey chick, baby macaw for sale, african grey for sale baby, ringneck parakeet for sale, yellow headed amazon, baby african grey parrot, military parrot for sale, mexican double yellow head parrot, double yellow headed amazon lifespan, baby african grey for sale, mexican double yellow head, yellow naped amazon price, macaw for sale, double yellow headed amazon for sale, red african grey, baby african grey, yellow head parrot for sale, double yellow headed amazon care with the well price and our services are very fast. Click here for MORE DETAILS......
    Contact - info@starhomebirds.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi there,
    Thank you so much for the post you do and also I like your post, Are you looking to Buy Red African Grey Parrots in the whole USA? We are military macaw baby ,red african grey for sale south Africa, red factor african grey, green naped amazon, double yellow amazon for sale, baby green wing macaw, yellow naped amazon for sale, red factor grey parrot, red factor african grey parrot, hythian macaw, timneh african grey babies for sale, scarlet macaw eggs, yellow headed amazon for sale, african grey baby birds for sale, summer fashion dresses 2018, baby grey parrot for sale, yellow naped amazon talking, baby african gray, african gray red factor, military macaw for sale, indian ringneck parakeet for sale, baby timneh african grey, indian parakeet for sale, blue indian ringneck for sale, yellow naped amazon for adoption, african grey chick, baby macaw for sale, african grey for sale baby, ringneck parakeet for sale, yellow headed amazon, baby african grey parrot, military parrot for sale, mexican double yellow head parrot, double yellow headed amazon lifespan, baby african grey for sale, mexican double yellow head, yellow naped amazon price, macaw for sale, double yellow headed amazon for sale, red african grey, baby african grey, yellow head parrot for sale, double yellow headed amazon care with the well price and our services are very fast. Click here for MORE DETAILS......
    Contact - info@starhomebirds.com

    ReplyDelete